|Vous êtes ici: Accueil > English > The Armenian issue > Historical facts and armenian allegations > Disinformation : the case of Hitler’s quote|
The historian Heath Lowry brings into light the Armenian lie
The 22nd of August 1939, so one week before the invasion of Poland, the German dictator is supposed to have made the following statement to his top German staff, secretly gathered in Obersalzberg : "I ordered the Death’s Heads units to exterminate all the Polish people, men and women, youngs and olds ... Anyway, who talks nowadays of the extermination of the Armenians ?"
The Armenian propagandists like to go on about repeting this sentence that has serious consequences since, according to them, it is said to be the warning signs of the future extermination of the Jews of Europe.
But what is really the truth ? Did Hitler really pronounce this sentence ? What does the historical sources reveal according to this subject ? ...
It’s a fact : up to now there is no document proving that Hitler did really pronounce these words. The Armenian propagandists claim that this sentence appears in the Nuremberg Court’s records. That’s a lie ! The Nuremberg records prove exactly the contrary of what the Armenians are saying !
The demonstration is done by the American historian, Heath Lowry, who has investigated and brought into light, point by point, the obnoxious Armenian manipulation !
The Armenian activists keep on propagating a shameless lie, and keep on distorting/manipulating the historical facts ! The right thing to do now is to denounce it as forcefully as possible !
The Tête de Turc team
The U. S. Congress and Adolf Hitler on the Armenians
Heath W. Lowry
Institute of Turkish Studies, Inc.
This article traces the history of a purported Adolf Hitler quote which cites the precedent of the world’s lack of reaction to the fate of Armenians during the First World War as a justification for his planned extermination of European Jewry in the course of the Second World War. By a detailed examination of the genesis of this quotation the author demonstrates that there is no historical basis for attributing such a statement to Hitler. Likewise, the author traces the manner in which this purported quote has entered the lexicon of U.S. Congressmen, and the manner in which it continues to be used by Armenian-Americans in their efforts to establish a linkage between their own history and the tragic fate of European Jewry during the Second World War. The author concludes with a plea to policy-makers that they focus their activities on the responsibilities of their offices and leave the writing of history to the historians.
A casual perusal of the pages of the Congressional Record (CR), of both the House and the Senate, on or about April 24, 1984, reveals a bipartisan group of our elected officials condemning the failure of the Republic of Turkey to acknowledge and assume responsibility for the "genocide" of the Armenian people allegedly perpetrated by the ottoman Empire in the course of the First World War. In 1984, a total of sixty-six such statements, fifty-seven by members of the House and nine by Senators, were read into the Congressional Record. Of these sixty-six tributes in support of Armenian Martyrs’ Day remembrances, exactly one third - twenty-two - contained one or another version of a quote attributed to Adof Hitler in which he purportedly responded to a query about his planned annihilation of European Jewry, by quipping : "Who, after all, speaks today of the extermination of the Armenians ?"
The Hitler Quote : Its Source and Its Avowed Focus
While the quiver of anti-Turkish invectives utilized by Armenian spokesmen contains a number of arrows, none is more frequently unleashed than this charge that Adolf Hitler was encouraged by his perception that the world had not reacted to alleged Ottoman mistreatment of its Armenians population during the First World War. He thus felt justified in going forward with his plan to exterminate European Jewry during the Second World War.
Given the widespread utilization of this quotation by Armenian spokesmen and their supporters, perhaps we should not be too surprised at the fact that il has found its way into the lexicon of our lawmakers. Even the dean of Armenian-American historians, Professor Richard Hovannissian of UCLA, stated in a 1983 address to the World Affairs Council of Pittsburgh, "Perhaps Adof Hitler had good cause in 1939 to declare, according to the Nuremberg trial transcripts, "Who, after all, speaks today of the extermination of the Armenians ?"  It is any wonder, then, that the following list of elected US officials repeat the same charge ?
It is noteworthy that sixteen of the above-listed officials (with the exception of Boxer, Courter, Dymally, Feighan, Ford, and Schumer) all clearly state that Hitler made his statement in support of his planned extermination of European Jewry. Equally noteworthy is the fact that the three Senators, Boschwitz, Levin, and Metzenbaum, and four of the members of the House, Berman, Gejdenson, Green, and Waxman, who made this linkage are themselves Jews.
The problem with this linkage is that there is no proof that Adolf Hitler ever made such a statement. Everything written to date has attributed the purported Hitler quote, not to primary sources, but to an article that appeared in the Times of London on Saturday, November 24, 1945. Said article, entitled "Nazi Germany’s Road To War,"  cites the quote and bases its attribution to Hitler on an address by him to his commanders-in-chief six years earlier, on August 22, 1939, a few days prior to his invasion of Poland. According to the unnamed author of the Times article, the speech had been introduced as evidence during the November 23, 1945, session of the Nuremberg Tribunal. Hitler is quoted as having stated, "Thus for the time being I have sent to the East only my Death’s Head units, with the order to kill without pity or mercy all men, women, and children of the Polish race or language. Who still talks nowadays of the extermination of the Armenians ?"  However, this version of the address was never accepted as evidence in this or any other session of the Nuremberg Tribunal.
Furthermore, the Times article of November 24, 1945, was not the earliest mention of Hitler’s alleged statement on the Armenians. Rather, this quotation, and indeed an entire text of a Hitler speech purportedly made at Obersalzberg on August 22, 1939, was first published in 1942 in a book entitled What About Germany ? and authored by Louis Lochner, a former bureau chief of the Associated Press in Berlin. 
I have issued the command - I’ll have anybody who utters one world of criticism executed by a firing squad - that our war aim does not consist in reaching certain lines, but in the physical destruction of the enemy. Accordingly, I have placed my death-head formations in readiness - for the present only in the East - with orders to them to send to death mercilessly and without compassion, men, women, and children of Polish derivation and language. Only thus shall we gain the living space [lebensraum] which we need. Who, after all, speaks today of the annihilation of the Armenians ? 
Of particular interest is the fact that while this "quotation" has appeared in literraly hundreds of publications in the past forty years, not a single one has ever cited Lochner’s book as its source. Likewise, no work has ever suggested that this statement made its first appearance, not in the course of the 1945 Nuremberg trials, but rather in the 1942 wartime publication of an American newspaperman.
Here there is no ambiguity in his meaning. If Hitler actually made this statement it obviously referred to his impending invasion of Poland and to the fate he envisioned for its citizenry ; it had absolutely nothing to do with his plans for the Jews of Europe. This fact in and of itself belies the allegations of those sixteen members of the U.S. Senate and House of Representatives who in their statements in conjunction with the April 24 remembrance of Armenian Martyrs’ Day, insisted that Hitler’s remarks expressed the rationale for his slaughter of the Jews.
When Adolf Hitler was planning the extermination of the Jewish people... (Aspin).
The Hitler Quote and the Nuremberg Trials
Having established that the first published appearance of Hitler’s alleged remark on the Armenians occurred in the 1942 Lochner book, we will now examine the history of its subsequent appearance in the course of the Nuremberg trials. It is necessary to state at the outset, however, that contrary to Professor Hovannisian in the above-mentioned quote, and a whole body of scholars writing on the Holocaust, the Nuremberg trials transcripts do not in fact contain the purported Hitler quote. Instead, the Nuremberg transcripts clearly demonstrate that the tribunal rejected Lochner’s version of Hitler’s Obersalzberg speech in favor of two more official versions found in confiscated German military records. These two records are, respectively, detailed notes of the August 22, 1939, meeting taken down by Admiral Hermann Boehm, Chief of the High Seas Fleet, who was in attendance  ; and an unsigned memorandum in two parts which provides a detailed account of Hitler’s August 22, 1939, remarks at Obersalzberg. This document originated in the Chief of the High Command of the Armed Forces (Oberkommando der Wehrmacht [OKW]) files and was captured by Armenian troops at Saalfelden in Austria. This was the chief document introduced by the prosecution at Nuremberg as evidence in the course of the session concerned with the invasion of Poland.  In addition, a third eyewitness account of the Obersalzberg meetings is found in the detailed diary kept by General Halder. 
In this presentation of condemning documents, concerning the initiation of the war in September 1939, I must bring to the attention of the Tribunal a group of documents concerning an address by Hitler to his chief military commanders, at Obersalzberg on 22 August 1939, just one week prior to the launching of the attack on Poland.
On 22 August 1939 Hitler had called together at Obersalzberg the three Supreme Commanders of the three branches of the Armed Forces, as well as the commanding generals bearing the title Commanders-in-Chief (Oberbefehlshaber).
One again we must not the obvious : neither of the Obersalzberg speeches introduced to the tribunal as evidence by Alderman (US-29/798-PS and US-30/1014-PS) contains any reference to Armenians.
Dr. Otto Stahmer, the defense counsel for Hermann Goring, took exception to Mr. Alderman’s presentation, stating, "The third document which was not read is, according to the photostatic copy in the Defense’s document room, simply typewritten. There is no indication of place or time of execution."  This led to the following exchange between the president of the tribunal and Dr. Stahmer:
The President : Well, we have got nothing to do with the third document, because it has not been read.
The discussion was then joined by prosecutor Alderman who made the following response to Dr. Stahmer’s charge that "the third document" (US-28) had been "leaked" to the press, and had already appeared in print :
On the other question referred to by counsel, I feel somewhat guilty. It is quite true that, by a mechanical slip, the press got the first document [US-28], which we never at all intended them to have. I feel someone responsible. It happened to be included in the document books which were handed up to the Court on Friday, because we had only intended to refer to it and give it an identification mark and not to offer it. I had thought that no documents would be released to the press until they were actually offered in evidence. With as large an organization as we have, it is very difficult to police all these matters. 
As the reader has doubtless discerned, US-28, the document provided to the prosecution by "an American newspaperman", which was not introduced as evidence after the original minutes of the Obersalzberg meeting were found, is the source of the alleged Hitler statement on Armenians. Aided by the passages quoted above from the Nuremberg transcript for November 26, 1945, we can now account for the story which appeared in the Times of London on Saturday, November 24, 1945. To make his deadline the unidentified Times reporter based his story on a leaked document on the assumption that it (US-28) would have been introduced in evidence by the time his story broke on Saturday. As the transcript clearly attests, the reporter’s expectations in this regard were not fulfilled. The results were far reaching : the world has been misled for almost forty years into thinking that the Nuremberg transcripts provided the Times reporter with his source for the quote attributed to Hitler, "Who still talks nowadays of the extermination of the Armenians ?" Armenian spokesmen have been free to argue that Adolf Hitler justified his planned annihilation of the Jews on the world’s failure to react to the alleged Ottoman genocide of the Armenians during the First World War. The Armenian success in this regard is clearly reflected in the April 24, 1984, Congressional Record.
What About Lochner’s What About Germany ?
What Louis Lochner the "unidentified American newspaperman" who provided the Nuremberg prosecutor with the purported transcript of the Obersalzberg meeting (US-28 or L-3, as it is variously known), which contains the alleged Hitler quote on the Armenians ? And, in fact was the version of the August 22, 1939, Obersalzberg speech published in Lochner’s 1942 book and that supplied by the "unidentified American newspaperman" at Nuremberg one and the same document ?
My coming with Louis Lochner [sic] had made the visit more exciting because he was no ordinary observer at the historic trial of the major war criminals. He had told me how he was responsible for the delivery of one of the most sensational of innumerable documents to prove Nazi conspirancy. This document, which described how Hitler maliciously planned the beginning of the Second World War, by an attack on Poland... was given to Louis Lochner in Germany just before America came to into the war, by a confidant of Colonel-General Von Beck, and, having first written on top of it "Ein Stuck gemeine Propaganda" [A piece of filthy propaganda] (to protect himself if the Germans searched him), he smuggled it to America. 
Since Lochner related the same story in the 1942 What About Germany ? in regard to his initial receipt of the purported Obersalzberg transcript, there can be no doubt that he was Alderman’s "unidentified American Newspaperman". 
By August 1939, General Beck was the acknowledged leader, along with Halder, of that faction of the German officer corps plotting against Hitler and the Nazis.  If, as Lochner claimed, he had received his version of the Obersalzberg speech via Beck, i.e., if it were leaked to him as an American newspaperman by forces opposed to Hitler, this could well account for Shirer’s assessment of the Lochner version as "embellishment a little by persons who were not present at the Berghof."  His assessment is in fact a gross understatement. A comparison of the Lochner version with the Nuremberg and Halder versions, shows that the former contains far more than a little "embellishment". Passages which would have lent themselves to stronger anti-Hitler propaganda found in the Lochner versions, are totally missing from the Nuremberg and Halder versions. These include the following phrases each of which, if published in the West, would have effectively portrayed Hitler in an extremely negative light to his allies (or potential allies), to the neutrals, and to the rest of the world :
Mussolini is threatened by a nit-wit of a king and the treasonable scoundrel of a crown prince.
In short, a comparison of the Lochner and Nuremberg versions of the August 22, 1939, Obersalzberg speech, strongly suggests that the one leaked to Lochner by the confidant of Beck was a strongly doctored version designed for propaganda purposes. This interpretation is supported by the fact that General Halder’s detailed diary entries for August 22, 1939, contain none of the above passages. Halder was, by that date, firmly in the rands of the anti-Hitler German officers, and presumably he would have had no interest in censoring his own diary had Hitler in fact made such statements. 
Why Has the Lochner Version Assumed the Importance That It Has ?
Why and how has such a spurious quotation of forty-five years ago become so important that it has been cited by no fewer than twenty-two members of the US Congress in 1984 ? The answer is complex and closely linked to American ethnic politics. Taking advantage of the flurry of press interest aroused by the activities of Armenian terrorist groups, activities which in the past decade have resulted in the assassinations of over thirty-five Turkish diplomats,  Armenian-American spokesmen have stepped up their ongoing campaign of vilification against the Republic of Turkey which they allege was responsible for the "genocide" of more than 1.5 million Armenians during the First World War. Unhampered by the limitations of logic or truth, these spokesmen attempt to justify current Armenian violence against innocent diplomats (none of whom were living in 1915), as a natural response to Armenian suffering in the course of the First World War.
Leaving aside the larger question of whether or not the fate of the Ottoman Armenians in 1914-1915 was in fact anything that could conceivably be termed a genocide, and focusing only on the matter at hand, the spurious Hitler quote, we find that three things come immediately to mind.
Excerpts from Congressional Speeches on the Armenians
SENATOR Rudy Boschwitz, R-Minn (CR - Senate, 4/25/84, p.S4852) : When Hitler first proposed his final solution, he was told that the world would never permit such a mass murder. Hitler silenced his advisers by asking : "Who remembers the Armenians ?"
SENATOR Carl Levin, D-Mich (CR Senate, 4/24/84, p. S4703) : but regrettably it was soon forgotten, not by the surviving Armenians, but by most of the rest of the world. So that when Adolf Hitler planned his invasion of Poland and the destruction of the Jewish people, he was able to scornfully state, "Who, after all, speaks today of the annihilation of the Armenians ?".
SENATOR Howard Metzenbaum, D-Ohio (CR - Senate, 4/24/84, p. S4719) : three years ago, in a speech given here in the Capital rotunda, Elie Wiesel, Chairman of the US Holocaust Memorial Council, made a telling point.
CONGRESSMAN LES ASPIN, D-Wis. (CR-House, 4/24/84, p. H2977) : two decades later, when Adolf Hitler was planning the elimination of the Jewish people, he is reported to have said, "Who remembers the Armenians ?"
CONGRESSMAN HOWARD BERMAN, D-Calif. (CR-House, 4/24/84, p. H2982) : it should be a source of concern to all of us that to this day Turkey does not acknowledge, despite eyewitness accounts, either the facts or its historical responsibility ; for the line from Armenia to Auschwitz is direct. The holocaust of European Jewry has its precedence in the events of 1915 to 1922. "Who still talks nowadays of the extermination of the Armenians" Hitler told his generals on the eve of the extermination of the Jews. The horrendous events of World War II overshadowed the Armenian genocide, and it is only recently, through the peaceful efforts of the Armenian Group, that the rest of the world has once again begun to recognize the collective agony of the Armenian people.
CONGRESSMAN THOMAS BLILEY, R-Va. (CR-House, 4/24/84, p. H2979) : Mr Speaker, I know that the actions of the Ottoman Government did not lead directly to the forced starvation of the Ukraine by Josef Stalin, the gas chambers of Auschwitz, the gruesome slaughter of the Cambodians, Idi Amin’s death campaign in Uganda, and the more recent actions in Matabeleland in Zimbabwe, but I know that human nature, even a warped and infamous human nature, needs the comfort of believing that it can get away with something before it proceeds. As an example I would cite Adolf Hitler’s statement concerning the final solution for the Jews of Europe when he said "Who now remembers the Armenians ?" If more proof is needed then we can all look up Idi Amin’s frequent statements of his adoration for Adolf Hitler as a man who knew how to handle a problem.
CONGRESSMAN EDWARD BOLAND, D-Mass. (CR-House, 4/24/84, p. H2975) : The silence with which the community of nations greeted the decimation of the Armenian people may have emboldened those who would later perpetrate similar acts. it certainly had an effect on Adolf Hitler who while planning the extermination of millions of Jews was asked how the world would respond to a program of mass murder. In reply Hitler said, "Who remembers the Armenians?"
CONGRESSWOMAN BARBARA BOXER, D-Calif. (CR-House, 4/24/84, p. H2977) : The repeated denials of these well documented crimes of the Ottoman Turkish regime call to mind the Nazi maxim that a big lie if often repeated becomes truth. Hitler himself cited the Armenian massacres as evidence that humanity cares nothing for the murder of a people.
CONGRESSMAN JIM COURTER, R-N.J. (CR-House, 4/24/84, p. H2977) : But there can be no doubt that this ignorance of history’ s darker events aids those who perpetrate them, and those who would do so in the future. It is known that Hitler cited the fact that the Armenian genocide was little known, little discussed and little remembered in his time. We can only imagine the conclusions he drew from this fact.
CONGRESSMAN MERVYN DYMALLY, D-Calif. (CR-House, 4/12/84, p. H2924) : Today, historians argue about the number of Armenians actually killed. Others claim that no genocide took place at all. This is a devastating conclusion to the survivors, whether they be Americans, Lebanese, Egyptians, French or citizens of any other country ... If we deny the Armenian Genocide - a historical event that has been well documented - we echo the words of Adoph [sic] Hitler who said, "Who still talks nowadays, of the extermination of Armenians?"
CONGRESSMAN EDWARD FEIGHAN, D-Ohio (CR-House, 4/24/84, p. H2971) : But only twenty years after the fact, the century’s first genocide was the "forgotten genocide." As Hitler paused on the edge of his own reign of terror, he asked "Who remembers the Armenians ?" And no one had. A world blind to the lessons of history saw them repeated on a wider scale.
CONGRESSWOMAN GERALDINE FERRARO, D-N.Y* I have dwelled on the Armenian genocide not because it is unique as a flagrant abuse of human rights, but precisely because it is not unique. The world knew about the Nazi Holocaust against the Jews - and failed to act. Those failures spread the shame of these unspeakable crimes against humanity far beyond those directly responsible for them.
*Quoted in the Armenian Reporter, July 26, 1984, p.2
CONGRESSMAN HAMILTON FISH, R-N.Y. (CR-House, 4/24/84, p. H2982) : In speaking of the consequences of the Jewish Holocaust, Adolf Hitler once remarked : "Who remembers the Armenians ?" Indeed it is our responsibility to do just that ; remember that which we would rather choose to forget.
CONGRESSMAN WILLIAM FORD, D-Mich. (CR-House, 4/24/84, p. H2981) : Even Adolf Hitler used past events to shape his own policies. In 1939 as he was beginning his invasion of Poland, Hitler ordered the mass extermination of its habitants, commenting, "Who, after all, speaks today of the annihilation of the Armenians ?" Humanity’s failure to remember the genocide of an entire people scarcely 25 years earlier gave Hitler the go ahead to exterminate millions of innocent people.
CONGRESSMAN SAM GEJDENSON, D-Conn. (CR-House, 4/25/84, p. E1766) : In the now infamous quote, Adolf Hitler, before beginning his Holocaust against the Jews, referred to international indifference in the face of the Armenian genocide. "Who," he asked, "remembers the Armenians ?"
CONGRESSMAN WILLIAM GREEN, R-N.Y (CR-House, 4/24/84, p. H2972) : When Hitler was about to begin the Holocaust and a member of his staff asked him what the world would think, Hitler is reported to have replied, "Who remembers the Armenians ?"
CONGRESSMAN RICHARD LEHMAN, D-Calif. (CR-House, 4/12/84, p. H2793): Questioned by an aide about his policy of Jewish genocide, Hitler said: "Who after all now remembers the annihilation of the Armenians ?"
CONGRESSMAN BRUCE MORRISON, D-Conn. (CR-House, 4/24/84, p. H2979) : Adolf Hitler took advantage of the world’s amnesia, looking at the Armenian genocide as a precedent for his own Holocaust perpetrated against Europe’s Jews. Hitler said, in a chilling remark made in 1939, "Who, after all, speaks today of the annihilation of the Armenians?"
CONGRESSMAN NICHOLAS MAVROULES, D-Mass. (CR-House, 4/24/84, p. H2979) : Sadly, however, the Armenian genocide would be surpassed by the Nazi holocaust in the 1930’s and 1940’s. Adolf Hitler, in an attempt to explain away his maniacal slaughter, would ask with a laugh: "Who, after all, speaks today of the annihilation of the Armenians ?"
CONGRESSMAN CHARLES SCHUMER, D-N.Y (CR-House, 4/24/84, p. H2976) : It is of paramount importance that we do not let this tragedy be forgotten with the passage of time. This act of inhumanity, based on religious and nationalistic grounds, was as terrible as any manmade catastrophe to that time yet only two decades later Hitler could ask, "Who remembers the Armenians?" Perhaps if the world had paid more attention to the plight of the Armenian massacre later tragedies could have been averted.
CONGRESSMAN JAMES SHANNON, D-Mass. (CR-House, 4/24/84, p. H2973) : This act of wholesale annihilation set the stage for Hitler’s attempted extermination of the Jewish people. He justified his plan to doubting coconspirators with the reasoning that no one remembered the Armenian genocide which had taken place only 15 years earlier.
CONGRESSMAN HENRY WAXMAN, D-Calif. (CR-House, 4/24/84, p. H2981) : This day serves to remind us that this first genocide of our century served as a precedent for the holocaust of World War II when more than 6 million people were destroyed by a government leader who responded : "Whoever cared about the Armenians ?" when it was suggested that world opinion would not allow the Nazis to get away with their attempt to eliminate the Jewish people.
Excerpts from the Lochner Version of the August 22, 1939, Obersalwberg Speech Dealing with the Planned Invasion of Poland
Lochner, 1942, p.2
Our strength consists of our speed and in our brutality. Genghis Khan led millions of women and children to slaughter - with premeditation and a happy heart. History sees in him solely the founder of a state. It is a matter of indifference to me what a weak western European civilization will say about me.
NCA, Volume VII, p. 753
Our strength is in our quickness and our brutality. Ghengis Khan had millions of women and children killed by his own will and with a gay heart. History sees only in him a great state builder. What weak Western European civilization thinks about me does not matter.
The Times, November 24, 1945, p. 4
Our strength is in our quickness and our brutality. Ghenghis Khan had millions of women killed by his own will and with a gay heart. History sees in him only a great state builder. What the weak European civilization thinks about me does not matter.
Excerpts from the Nuremberg Versions of the August 22, 1939, Obersalzberg Speech Dealing with the Planned Invasion of Poland
Destruction of Poland in the foreground. The aim is elimination of living forces, not the arrival at a certain line : Even if war should break out in the West, the destruction of Poland shall be the primary objective. Quick decision because of the season.
Have no pity, Brutal attitude. 80 million people shall get what is their right. Their existence has to be secured. The strongest has the right. Greatest severity.
First aim : advance to the Vistula and Narew. Our technical superiority will break the nerve of the Poles. Every newly created Polish force shall again be broken at once. Constant war of attrition.
New German frontier according to healthy principles. Possibly a protectorate as a buffer. Military operations shall not be influenced by these reflections. Complete destruction of Poland is a military aim. Pursuit until complete elimination.
Boehm, August 22, 1939
The goal is the elimination and destruction of Poland’s military power even if war should begin in the west. A swift, successful out-come in the East offers the best prospects for restricting the conflict.
A suitable propaganda cause will be advanced for the conflict. The credibility of this is unimportant. Right lies with the victor.
We can and must believe in the value of the German soldier. In times of crisis he has generally retained his nerve, while the leadership has lost theirs...
Once again : the first priority is the swiftness of the operations. To adapt to each new situation, to shatter the hostile forces, wherever they appear, and to the last one.
This is the military goal which is the prerequisite for the narrower political goal of later drawing up new frontiers.
Halder, August 22, 1939
Aim : annihilation of Poland - elimination of its vital forces. It is not a matter of gaining a specific line or new frontier, but rather the annihilation of an enemy, which constantly must be attempted by new ways.
Solution : Means immaterial. The victor is never called on to vindicate his actions. We are not concerned with having justice on our side, but solely with victory.
Execution : Harsh and remorseless. Be steeled against all signs of compassion !
Speed : Faith in the German soldier, even if reverses occur.
Of paramount importance are the wedges [which must be driven] from the southeast to the Vistula, and from the north to the Narev and the Vistula.
New Frontiers : New Reich territory. Outlying protectorate territory. Military operations must not be affected by regard for the future frontiers.
Historian of Armenian Descent Says Frequently Used Hitler Quote Is Nothing But a Forgery
Baden-Baden, W. Germany - Dr. Robert John, a historian and political analyst of Armenian descent from New York City, declared here that a commonly used quotation of an alleged statement by Adolf Hitler concerning the Armenian massacres was a forgery and should not be used.
Dr. John demonstrated how he had traced the original document in the Military Branch of the National Archives of the U.S.A. after being handed a folder bearing the quotation at a rally outside the United Nations building in New York following the Turkish invasion of Cyprus.
The quotation: "Our strength is in our quickness and our brutality... For the time being I have sent to the east only Death’s Heads units, with the order to kill without pity or mercy all men, women and children... Who talks nowadays of the extermination of the Armenians?"
Dr. John showed slides of this document, undated and unsigned, with some words cut out of the last page. The statement was supposed to have been made at a meeting of the top German staff of the Obersalzberg on August 22, 1939. The document was released to the international press covering the Nuremberg War Crimes trials on Friday, November 23, 1945. The trials had commenced that Monday. The document was one of several made available to the press that day. Two-hundred-fifty copies were given to press correspondents, but only five copies were given to the 17 defense counsels - 24 hours before the Court convened on Monday!
Much later in the trial, the German defense lawyers were able to introduce the most complete account of the address, taken down by German Admiral Hermann Boehm, which runs to 12 pages in translation. There is no mention of the Armenians or the rest of the "quotation."
Dr. Robert John said he believed that the document was introduced to create a climate of hate which was needed to stifle the protests of eminent American jurists such as Sen. R. Taft and Chief Justice Harland Stone. He had discussed it with Gen. Telford Taylor, who had said, "I know the document you mean, I don’t know its provenance, and I have not used it in my own work."
"We all believe that violence breeds violence" said Dr. John. "There has been an increase in Armenian violence since this false inflammatory statement was given publicly. Films like ’The Day After’ are a form of violence, and should not be shown to children - who are unable to evaluate their content. Films about the "Holocaust" are a form of violence and are harmful to us as well as to Jews.There is a high probability that the surprising violence and brutality shown by the Israelis towards the Palestinians, may be a result of being frequently exposed to these old scenes. Just as parents who abuse their children have often been abused themselves."
Dr. John briefly traced the history of atrocity propaganda, particularly from the British - and later - American view. Real atrocities certainly occurred, but the deliberate fabrication and dissemination of atrocity stories increased the probability of their occurring. "Hate hurts the hater and hated. We are still living in the haze of distortions and actual horrors which occurred so long ago." he commented.
"The time has come to stop psychologically damaging ourselves and our children by ’Holocaust studies’ and ’Holocaust museums’," he continued. "The Armenian, the Jew, or the African, should not damage their development with a continual conditioning of hate, neither should spurious guilt be visited upon others. These negative preoccupations and obsessions are obstructing our evolution."
Dr. John, whose paper is entitled "Information and Misinformation," hails from Armenian parents who moved from New Julla, Iran to India. His father changed his name from Hovhanes to "John," and subsequently the family moved to England. Dr. John studies law in England and holds a doctoral degree in political science from London University. He is presently a contributor to the London, England based The Middle East Magazine monthly, and in addition to giving lectures, is a frequent contributor to numerous magazines and publications. He is also the author of Palestine Diary, and specializes in Middle Eastern issues, including the Palestinian issue.
From The Armenian Reporter, Vol. XVII, NO. 40 August 2, 1984
Copyright © 2000-2011 Tête de Turc - www.tetedeturc.com - firstname.lastname@example.org